Accountability
If we think about it, recalls issued by automakers have become routine for us as motorists. Not a day goes by without a fresh set of new car recalls being published by the NHTSA and carmakers about irregularities and quality-control issues in vehicles that have made it into the production line and eventually onto the roads. The truth is, while we’re used to it, it doesn’t change the fact that any recall is a nuisance and a hassle for the owner, who bought the car with the idea that the automaker built it correctly and checked it thoroughly.
A new piece of legislation was signed in New Jersey and aims to punish these recall mistakes by automakers by making them pay more for recall and warranty-claimed repairs. Unsurprisingly, the carmakers aren’t happy to pay more even if the mistake was on their end, and are now fighting back against the new law.

Getty Images
Car Makers vs. New Jersey
A report by Automotive News highlights that the Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act, signed into law in September of last year and taking effect this April 2026, is drawing the ire of certain automakers. Auto giants Ford, Honda, Stellantis, and Volkswagen all banded together to file a lawsuit in November 20 seeking to block the legislation from continuing.
According to this group of brands, the law is unconstitutional and essentially gives the dealerships a “blank check” to charge the brands any amount for repairs stemming from recalls and warranty claims. The lawsuit also claims that in the months since the new law took effect, dealers in the state of New Jersey have demanded and declared payment at labor rates and multipliers that compel manufacturers to pay for hours that no technician works, that surpass what comparable dealers charge for the same work, and that exceed what retail customers pay.
In short, automakers don’t want to pay more money for wages, which is estimated to cost them an additional $375 million in New Jersey and could reach $2 billion over 5 years. All of this is in the context of the more than 500 new car dealerships in the state. NJ CAR President Laura Perrotta said she is confident that the state will reject the arguments brought forward by the brands.

Getty Images
Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act
Under the new law, automakers must reimburse dealerships at no less than the retail rate for warranty and recall work. This comes out to the car maker paying dealerships and workers 1.5 percent per month of the value of any recalled vehicle classified under a “stop sale” or “don’t drive” order. The brands themselves have to cover all related costs like holding inventory, parts, and labor. Recall and warranty repairs are also one of the biggest income generators for a dealership.
