My advance apologies to all the Jodi Picoult fans out there.
I don’t understand the hype.
Hollow Bones was my first attempt to jump into her work. The book club pick was popular among our crew, so I made my way to my local bookstore, picked up a copy, and dove in. I wanted to love it. Or at least understand why Picoult has such a devoted following.
Unfortunately, that didn’t happen.

Characters That Never Came to Life
From the beginning, the characters just felt, well, hollow.
The faces and shapes were nebulous. I couldn’t picture the characters or their environments with any ease. And while this might have been an intentional technique on the author’s part, it felt flat to me.
I never developed that wonderful sense of familiarity that comes from spending hundreds of pages with fictional people. I couldn’t see them clearly, and I certainly didn’t feel particularly invested in what happened to them.
For me, that’s a problem.
I can forgive a lot in a novel if I care about the characters. Give me flawed, frustrating, complicated people who feel real, and I’ll happily follow them through just about anything.
But these characters never made that leap off the page.
Too Many Themes, Not Enough Truth
Hollow Bones is a bit of a psychological thriller.
It’s also a 9/11 novel.
And a story about postpartum psychosis.
Oh, and there’s a dash of illegal immigration thrown in, too.
In short, too many things at once, and none of them felt TRUE.
I don’t mind an ambitious novel. In fact, I love books that tackle complicated subjects and challenge the reader to think differently. But there’s a difference between exploring difficult issues and simply piling them onto a plot. With all the AI slop out there, I admit I found myself wondering whether Picoult had asked Claude to identify the most important literary themes for 2026 and then decided to include them all. I’m exaggerating, of course, but that’s how manufactured the story felt to me. Rather than revealing something meaningful about the human condition, the various plotlines seemed designed to keep raising the emotional stakes. And eventually, I stopped caring.

Plot Twists Aren’t Everything
I will give Picoult credit for one thing: she clearly knows how to construct a complicated plot.
Her ability to weave multiple storylines together is impressive. There are plenty of moving pieces, and she works hard to bring them all into alignment. And then there are the twists. Oh, the twists.
Picoult really gives it her all trying to surprise the reader. But for me, surprise isn’t the same thing as satisfaction. The final twist—yet another tragedy just pages from the end—almost made me laugh. It was so absurd, so ill-timed, and so intentionally emotionally manipulative that I couldn’t summon the reaction I suspect the author wanted.
I didn’t feel devastated. I thought, “Oh dear, it’s really come to this.” And that’s not exactly the emotional payoff I’m looking for after more than 400 pages.
Interesting Facts Don’t Make a Great Novel
If you’re a plot-driven reader who loves collecting interesting bits of information along the way, there are things to enjoy here. Picoult weaves in details about Indigenous culture, mosaic making, and even how to read a lie detector. There’s no shortage of research or subject matter.
But I kept wondering what all this information was doing for the story.
I love learning something new from a novel. I love finishing a book and feeling that I’ve gained a fresh perspective or discovered something about the world.
Here, the information felt more like a collection of interesting facts than an essential part of the storytelling. There’s plenty to keep a reader occupied. But being occupied isn’t the same thing as being moved.
Where Is the Beautiful Writing?
This is where I really struggle with Hollow Bones.
The writing is completely unquotable.
There’s nothing particularly beautiful in the prose. No sentence I wanted to underline. No passage I wanted to read again simply for the pleasure of the words.
And I know that’s not what every reader wants.
Some people read for plot. Others read for characters, setting, language, or the pure pleasure of escaping into another world.
I want a little of everything.
I don’t expect every novel to be a literary masterpiece, but I do want to feel that the author has something to say—and has found an interesting or beautiful way to say it.
Hollow Bones never gave me that feeling.

Final Thoughts
I know Jodi Picoult has legions of devoted fans, and I can understand why readers who enjoy complicated plots and dramatic twists might find plenty to like here.
But Hollow Bones wasn’t for me.
The characters felt thin, the themes were overcrowded, and the emotional manipulation became increasingly difficult to ignore. By the final pages, I wasn’t moved by the tragedy. I was exhausted by it.
This book might entertain you. It might distract you. You might even learn a few interesting things along the way. But it won’t inspire you. What can I say? My standards are high.
One-line takeaway: Hollow Bones is a twist-filled, ambitious novel that tries to tackle everything but left me feeling very little.
For fans of: Jodi Picoult, psychological thrillers, family dramas, multiple storylines, unexpected plot twists, and novels that tackle contemporary social issues.
Where I read it: A book club selection I picked up at my local bookstore. Read at Twin Farms, a gorgeous Vermont retreat .
You can find this—and everything else I’m reading this year—on my running 2026 book list.
The post Hollow Bones Book Review: Why Jodi Picoult’s Novel Left Me Cold appeared first on Mom Trends.